Which LED lamps are better for the home: rating from the TOP 20 best lamp models

Unfortunately, LED lamps were not as long-lived as expected. And even though each lamp has a warranty for a period of one to five years, problems often arise with the exchange of failed lamps if the lamps were purchased in online stores, in markets or in hardware stores near home.

In Auchan, Leroy Merlin, Castorama and other large stores there are no problems with exchange, and even if the receipt is lost, it can be restored by giving the approximate date of purchase.

The second and third reasons are fairly low prices and a large assortment compared to markets and small shops.

I bought 120 lamps from the Leroy Merlin store and tested them to understand which lamps I could buy there and which ones I shouldn’t.

Leroy now sells about 130 types of LED lamps from eight brands: more than 50 models of lamps from its own brand Lexman (these lamps are guaranteed for five years), about 30 models of Osram (2-year warranty), several models of lamps from Philips, Uniel, Wolta , IEK, Electrostandard, Bellight (mostly 2 year warranty).

First, let's define the criteria for choosing good lamps:

• there should be no light pulsation (pulsation coefficient should not exceed 5%);
• color rendering index (CRI, Ra) must be more than 80;
• there must be a driver with stabilization, allowing them to operate in a wide range of supply voltage without fluctuations in brightness;
• luminous flux and other parameters must correspond to those stated.

Measuring instruments:

• luminous flux – two-meter integrating sphere and Instrument Systems spectrometer;
• lighting angle and consumption characteristics – Viso Light Spion;
• power consumption – Robiton PM-2;
• color rendering index, color temperature and ripple – Uprtek MK350D;
• the minimum operating voltage at which the luminous flux decreased by no more than 10% of the nominal - Lamptest-1, Stihl Instab 500 stabilizer, Suntek TDGC2-0.5 LATR and Aneng AN8001 precision multimeter.

For convenience, I divided all the lamps into categories, in each of which they, in turn, are divided by base and color temperature. In each subcategory, lamps are sorted by declared luminous flux.

What types of LED lamps are there?

To correctly select such lamps, it is necessary, first of all, to decide on some important parameters, such as:

• what kind of light source they will serve (main, additional);
• what is the lighting area;
• what shade of light should be;
• what is the purpose of the room?

Note that lamps for household use can be based on the type of base

• E14/E27 . These connection options are the most common. The number in the designation says what the diameter of the spiral is (mm), and the letter E indicates that Edison invented them;
• G9 . They differ in that the connection occurs through a two-pin connector (with a 9 mm distance between the pins).

LED lamps can also be classified according to their shape :

• traditional (represent candles, pears or flasks);
• corn - a diode circuit is located around the perimeter of the cylinder.

Finally, you can classify by type of control and sensors :

• models with motion/light sensor;
• rechargeable (powered by AA batteries or, as an option, a battery);
• with remote control;
• smart models (such lamps are controlled via wi-fi; a special application is used to adjust the color and brightness of the lighting).

3 years have passed. Yesterday it burned out!

Time flies amazingly fast. It would seem that just recently it was 2016, autumn. That's when I brought home and discreetly screwed an Ecola LED corn lamp into the chandelier. And the household immediately noticed that “it seemed to have somehow become lighter.” Since then the lamp has worked every day. No comments or complaints.

But yesterday something terrible happened. No, not a fire or anything like that. First the lamp blinked. I attributed this to a voltage failure in the network. And after another ten minutes it simply went out. Without any loud statements. Simple - that's it.

I tried to screw it into another cartridge - in vain. It just doesn’t light up and, if you listen closely, it makes a very quiet whistle. Maybe it was there before - I don’t know. It's a shame. The thing is not cheap. Upon inspection, no possibilities for disassembly were found. I suspect that some element inside has failed. The LEDs are most likely intact. But you won’t be able to figure it out on your own.

One of these days I will be in a store where they are sold. I'll ask a question. Maybe the situation will somehow be resolved. I'll write about the results.

Article on the topic: IKEA battery-powered LED table lamp. Review. Review How we bought LED lamps for our home. Review. Photo. Savings calculation

• Back
• Forward

Advantages and disadvantages

LED lighting, like any other technology, has its own advantages and disadvantages that you should definitely know about.

pros

• economical energy consumption;
• can be connected to a dimming system;
• long service life (from 3 to 8 years);
• environmental friendliness.

Minuses

• the parameters indicated on the packaging may not match;
• quite high cost;
• low quality of parts (especially diodes).

TOP 5 LED lamps with E27 base (analogous to “weaving”)

The popularity of this power is explained by the fact that it makes it possible to minimally illuminate rooms up to 15 square meters. Let's take a look at the analogues of “hundreds” (100 W incandescent lamps), which are considered the best according to buyers.

No5. Bellight E27 10 W

At Leroy Merlin you can find inexpensive options, including their own production. These bulbs, made of frosted glass, have a white, cool light. The color temperature is 4000 K, the voltage is from 220 V to 230 V. The shape is pear, the luminous flux is 840 Lumens.

pros

• the price is quite affordable;
• the lights don't blink.

Minuses

• no serious deficiencies were identified.

No4. Navigator NLL-A60 6500K

This model is also pear-shaped and made of white frosted glass. Gives cool light, optimal for everyday use. When consuming 220-230 V, the device produces a luminous flux of 850 Lm. The color temperature reaches 6500 K, the light beam has an angle of 270 degrees.

pros

• saves electrical energy, and therefore money;
• work long enough (30 thousand hours).

Minuses

• no significant deficiencies were identified.

No3. Feron E27-E40 LED

The service life of these diode lamps is long - up to 30 thousand hours. They provide white, cool light that helps you concentrate on work (your eyes don't get tired). An excellent option for a spacious room, kitchen or dining room. The color flux in this case is 4700 lm, and the color temperature is 6400 K. Pear-shaped, operates on a 220-230 V network.

pros

• immediately bright light, without “overclocking”;
• there are adapters for different types of base;
• long service life;
• the light is very bright.

Minuses

• quite high cost.

No2. LED E27-E40

Powerful and bright cold glow is perfect for spacious classrooms and halls. The shape of the lamp is futuristic (pear with corners), and a good cooling system is provided. The voltage is standard, the luminous flux reaches 4700 lm. As for the color temperature, it is 6400 K.

pros

• original design;
• long service life;
• high power.

Minuses

• There is no possibility to connect a dimmer.

No1. Gauss LED 12W

According to the manufacturer, such lamps can last up to 35 years (warranty period is 3 years), which indicates the high quality of the products. The shape of the lamp is pear-shaped, with the cooling system taking up most of the structure. With a standard voltage of 220-230 W, the lamps have a power of 12 W, a luminous flux of 1220 lm and a color temperature of 2700 K. They have a height of 20 cm.

pros

• the glow is bright and warm;
• electricity is consumed economically;
• long service life.

Minuses

• no significant deficiencies were identified.

Positive aspects of the brand

The brand undoubtedly has positive aspects. These are the immutable ones:

• price - unlike its eminent counterparts, the Eastern European company firmly adheres to the policy of accessibility in relation to its products, solutions are constantly being sought to replace expensive parts with simple analogues while maintaining performance;
• large selection - the brand does not pursue exclusivity, looking for options for a wide variety of tastes and circumstances, both traditional and special;
• unusualness - among the proposals you can find both stylish, minimalist design and bright, unusual shapes and bold combinations.

At one time, it was Ecola that produced stunning colored spiral light bulbs, from one glance at which a wave of positivity and curiosity arose in those passing by.

The colored light bulbs are entirely the company's initiative. There are no other brands that produce something similar, or their analogues are too few. The brand's engineers warn that if you connect several different colors into one chandelier at once, according to the laws of physics the light will turn out white

The most important thing is that manufacturers do not rest on their laurels, but listen sensitively to feedback, instantly responding to customer demand with an actual offer. The company is constantly developing, and today is able to provide real, working quality.

TOP 4 lamps with E14 socket (analogous to “weave”)

E-14 is a wide base, which is also very popular and is suitable for most lighting fixtures in the house.

No4. Feron ELC73

Good energy-saving products in the shape of a candle. The light is cold and white (color temperature - 4000 K), visually it is almost no different from the indicators of the classic “weaving”. At a voltage of 220-230 V, the power value of the product is 11 W. If we talk about the luminous flux, then in this case it is 540 Lm.

pros

• very affordable price (from 13 rubles);
• good power and other characteristics.

Minuses

• service life is relatively short (up to 8 thousand hours).

No3. Xflash XF-E14-TC-P

According to the manufacturer, such a lamp can last up to 50 thousand hours. The light is cold and strong, the luminous flux is abundant, and therefore the room will be illuminated in the same way as a 100 W light bulb. The model has a power of 10 W and a color temperature of 4090 K. It is cylindrical in shape and has a height of 11.6 cm.

pros

• dimmable lamps available;
• long service life.

Minuses

• ripple value – 1.3%.

No2. ASD LED LED-SHAR-STD

A spherical lamp that provides a cool glow. Can last 30 thousand hours. Uses 10 times less electricity than a hundred square meters. With a standard voltage of 220-230 V, the product has a power of 10 W. The color flux is only 400 lm, and the color temperature is 4000 K.

pros

• low price;
• good power;
• impressive service life.

Minuses

• no serious deficiencies were identified.

No1. Foton Lighting FL-LED-R50 ECO 9W

This model has high color (6400 K), which provides bright light as close to daylight as possible. The lamp can be installed in both open and closed lighting fixtures. It has a power of 8 W and a luminous flux of 720 lm. The shape is spherical, height is only 5 cm.

pros

• high quality at a good price;
• long service life (30 thousand hours).

Minuses

• Dimmer connection is not provided.

Review of manufacturers

Many manufacturers around the world are engaged in the production of LED lamps. The bulk are companies from China and Europe. Chinese companies are divided into “semi-basement” and certified. The products of the former should not be considered for purchase, as their use may even be dangerous.

Certified light bulbs undergo quality control and mandatory certification. It is worth noting that many manufacturers are moving their production facilities to China. This is done to reduce the cost of the production process, while the quality of the product remains unchanged. Popular brands include:

1. Feron. A Chinese brand distinguished by the variety of appearance of its lamps and their resistance to atmospheric changes.
2. Camelion. The products are popular in European countries due to the reliability of the power supplies used in LED emitters.
3. Jazzway. A recognized company in the Russian lighting market. During its existence, more than 30 million lamps were produced.
4. Gauss. The service life of this brand's products is about 20 years, which is ensured by an automated quality control regime.
5. Maxus. The lamps are exceptionally resistant to mechanical damage due to the absence of glass in the bulbs.
6. BBK. A Chinese brand that has developed a driver that eliminates ripple and protects the emitter from overheating and voltage surges over a wide range.
7. ASD. The company's products are aimed at the Russian sales market. This name is associated with low energy consumption, long service life and safety.
8. Osram. A high-tech company from Germany, which is the world's largest manufacturer of LED lamps. Winner of awards for high quality products and innovative developments.
9. Philips. The products of the Dutch company are manufactured in China. It is considered a middle peasant among manufacturers with affordable prices.
10. Eurolamp. It features a wide range of LED lamps with a well-thought-out cooling system. The German company produces products that meet European standards and are distinguished by affordable prices.

You may be interested in: Connecting a switch with an LED yourself

TOP 4 models with E27 socket (to replace 60 W lamps)

We are talking here only about the power of the luminous flux, because in other respects incandescent lamps are significantly inferior. Thus, diode lamps consume three times less electricity, do not heat the air around them and do not heat themselves, and they do not blink.

No4. Philips LED A60-8w-865-E27

An excellent option for budget lighting of small rooms and corridors. With a temperature of 6500 K and a power of 8 W, the model contributes to significant energy savings. The luminous flux is 806 lm, the voltage is from 220 V to 240 V. The service life reaches 40 thousand hours.

pros

• affordable price;
• absence of IR and UV rays.

Minuses

• There is no possibility to connect a dimmer.

No3. Gauss Led 7W

One of the best medium power bulbs, providing a white and warm glow. The base has a diameter of 14 mm, the voltage can vary from 150 V to 365 V, and the color temperature is 2700 K. With a power of 7 W, the light bulb can last 35 thousand hours. The shape is soffit.

pros

• you can connect a dimmer;
• There are varieties of the model in the form of a candle and having a warm color temperature.

Minuses

• no significant deficiencies were identified.

No2. Osram Duo Click CLA60 6.3W/827

The dispersion angle of the warm glow of 2700 K is in this case 200 degrees. The shape of the product is a traditional glass pear. The voltage can vary from 220V to 240V and the power is 6.7W. Luminous flux is only 610 lm.

pros

• relatively good service life (15 thousand hours);
• model protection degree - IP40;
• low price.

Minuses

• There are no significant shortcomings.

No1. Philips 806 Lumen 2700K

The product gives a warm, soothing light, ideal for the bedroom (helps create an intimate environment). The filament threads in the composition provide a rather attractive design. With a standard voltage of 220-240 V, the product has a power of 8 W. The shape of the model is a ball. The luminous flux is 806 lm, while the color temperature reaches 2700 K. The lamp will last up to 15 thousand hours.

pros

• Compatible with switches that provide brightness adjustment.

Minuses

• no serious deficiencies were identified.

How we took measurements

As a tester, we used the universal Power Meter, which allows us to almost instantly obtain data on the energy consumption of any household appliance. In addition to power consumption, we also simultaneously measured the heating temperature of the light bulb body using an XL830L multimeter, because overheating is one of the most common reasons for lamp failure.

1 of 4

To eliminate the possibility of defects or accidents, we took three copies of each lamp model (8 brands in total). Each was previously operated for 500 hours. You can see the measurement results in our table.

TOP 4 LEDs with E27 base (to replace 200 W lamps)

Having different shapes, such lamps have the same lighting power. Installed where bright light is required or in large rooms.

No4. OSRAM HQL LED 3000

The body is elongated and completely covered with diodes (the lamp looks like an ear of corn). High power, service life reaches 32 thousand hours. The model can be used for outdoor lighting, as it is resistant to temperature changes. High brightness combined with neutral light. The power is 27 W, the luminous flux is 3000 lm, and the color temperature reaches 4000 K.

pros

• resistance to temperature changes (from -20 to +60 degrees);
• a large area is illuminated;
• excellent power of the product.

Minuses

• quite high price.

No3. Philips Led 27 W 6500 K

The model emits a cool glow that is close to natural. An excellent option for the role of the main light source. With a luminous flux of 3000 lm and a power of 27 W, such a lamp can last 15 thousand hours. Color temperature is 6500 K. Pear-shaped.

pros

• economical consumption;
• no flicker;
• affordable price.

Minuses

• there is no possibility of connecting a dimmer;
• There is no way to adjust the brightness.

No2. Gauss A67 6500 K

The product provides white, soft and visually pleasing light; An excellent option for common areas. The permissible voltage is from 180 V to 220 V, the power value reaches 25 W. Having a luminous flux of 2150 lm and a color temperature of 6500 K, the lamp can last up to 25 thousand hours.

pros

• no flicker;
• good service life;
• An excellent option for common areas.

Minuses

• no serious deficiencies were identified.

No1. Navigator NLL-A70

This model has a warm and white light, the light beam dispersion angle is 230 degrees. An excellent option, for example, for a bedroom. The permissible voltage is from 180 V to 220 V, while the power is 20 W. The luminous flux is 1700 lm, and the color temperature is 4000 K. The shape is pear, height is 15.2 cm.

pros

• long service life (40 thousand hours);
• good characteristics, including power.

Minuses

• The lamp is not suitable if you need to smoothly adjust the brightness of the lighting.

TOP 3 LED models E27 (to replace 150 W lamps)

Such lamps are optimal for lighting rooms up to 25 square meters. m.

No3. Osram SST CLA150 20.3 W/827 E27 FR Dim

These LED ceiling lights are a great option for your home. They provide warm and cozy light without hesitation or flickering. The flask is made of frosted glass. The light beam scattering angle is 200 degrees. With a luminous flux of 2452 lm and a temperature of 2700 K, the power of the product is 21 W.

pros

• you can connect a dimmer;
• The output indicators correspond to the declared ones.

Minuses

• no significant deficiencies were identified.

No2. Nanosvet E27 2700K

The lamp provides light that is pleasant and comfortable for the eyes without yellowness. It has a voltage of 220 V and a power of 18 W. The shape is cylindrical, the color temperature is 2700 K. The model can last 15 thousand hours.

pros

• no flicker;
• can be used with switches that have backlighting.

Minuses

• not the lowest price.

No1. OSRAM LS CLA150

A pear-shaped lamp with bright warm light, an excellent option for large areas. At standard voltage, its power is 20.3 W, and the luminous flux is 2452 lm. The color temperature indicator is 2700 K. Lasts up to 15 thousand hours.

pros

• no blinking;
• the product begins to illuminate without “overclocking,” that is, immediately.

Minuses

• no serious deficiencies were found.

Total: what to buy?

Obviously, foreign brands OSRAM and Philips hold the mark. But the domestic ERGOLUX and Navigator were almost as good as them in our test, and they cost significantly less. Of course, the issue of resource remains open, but even if these lamps last less, the savings will still be noticeable.

This is interesting:

• How to fix an LED light bulb yourself: step-by-step instructions